Nearly 4 in 5 U.S. Small Businesses Can Be Impersonated by Email: 2026 National Study

Nearly four out of five small businesses in America’s largest cities have left their email open to forgery, making it simple for a scammer to send a bill, a wire request or a “secure document” link that appears to come from a company the customer already trusts.

MailWatchman examined the public email settings of 2,607 independent businesses in and around 22 major U.S. cities, from New York and Los Angeles to Nashville and Portland. The review covered six kinds of businesses where a convincing fake email can cost a customer real money: dental offices, medical practices, law firms, accounting and tax firms, real estate offices and contractors. Of those, 2,050 (79%) lacked an enforced DMARC policy, the free setting that tells Gmail, Outlook and other mail systems to refuse messages forged in a company’s name.

Just 557 businesses, about one in five, had their domain set to block or quarantine fake mail. Only 245 (9%) had taken the final step of telling mail systems to reject forgeries outright.

79%
can be impersonated by email (2,050 of 2,607)
49%
have no DMARC record at all
29%
have DMARC set to monitor only, which blocks nothing
21%
actually block or quarantine forged email (557 of 2,607)

The result closely matches what we found closer to home. In an earlier study of 366 businesses in Santa Clara County, California, 80% could be impersonated. The national figure, 79%, suggests the problem is not a regional quirk. It is the norm.

The stakes are high. In its 2025 Internet Crime Report, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center logged 24,768 complaints of business email compromise, the industry term for scams that use a trusted company’s email to redirect payments, with reported losses of just over $3 billion. Real estate fraud accounted for another 12,368 complaints and $275 million in losses.

Those figures reflect only what victims reported, and they include schemes that DMARC alone cannot stop, such as hacked mailboxes and look-alike web addresses. But forging a company’s real address is the cheapest, simplest version of the scam. For most of the businesses we checked, nothing stands in its way.

How the scam works

Email was built in an era when no one expected to need proof of who sent a message. Anyone with basic software can type any address into the “From” line, much as anyone can write any return address on an envelope. Three records published in a company’s domain settings, known as SPF, DKIM and DMARC, were added over the years to close that gap.

SPF lists the servers allowed to send mail for a domain. DKIM adds a digital signature to each message. DMARC ties the two together and tells the receiving mail system what to do when a message claiming to be from the company fails those checks: deliver it anyway, send it to spam, or reject it.

Without DMARC, or with DMARC left in its “monitor only” mode (p=none), a forged message can land in a customer’s inbox looking exactly like the real thing. A patient receives a “past due balance” notice from what appears to be the dental office. A home buyer, days from closing, receives “updated wiring instructions” from what appears to be the agent. A client is asked to upload tax documents through a new link that appears to come from the accountant.

The business usually never sees it. Forged messages don’t pass through the company’s own mail system, so they never show up in its sent folder. The first sign is often a confused or angry call from a customer who has already paid.

Dental offices are the most exposed

Share of businesses in each industry that can be impersonated by email:

Dental offices stood out. Of 867 practices checked, 744 (86%) could be impersonated, and 57% had no DMARC record at all. One in eight dental offices (111 of 867) had neither SPF nor DMARC, the two most basic protections. Dental offices send a steady stream of billing and insurance email, and patients expect to receive it, which is exactly what makes a forged message believable.

Accounting and tax firms (79%), law firms (78%), real estate offices (78%) and contractors (76%) were clustered closely together. The differences among those four groups are small enough that no one can claim to be doing well. In each, roughly three of every four businesses could be impersonated.

That is a particular concern for the businesses that move the most money. Real estate offices and law firms routinely handle down payments, settlements and trust-account funds, yet only 22% of real estate offices and 22% of law firms were enforcing DMARC. The FBI’s 2025 report describes home buyers who wired their closing funds to criminals after receiving fake wire instructions by email from what they believed was their title company. With tax season approaching, accountants face a familiar spike in fake requests for W-2s and payment.

Medical practices did best, at 67%, and were the most likely to have finished the job: about one in three (146 of 445) enforced DMARC. That is still a majority of practices whose patients can be sent fake bills or portal links. It is also a reminder of how much local results can vary. In our Santa Clara County study, medical practices were tied with dental offices as the most exposed group.

Half-finished setups are everywhere

One of the clearest patterns in the national data, as in the local study, is how often businesses started the job and stopped. Of the 1,327 businesses that had published any DMARC record, 755 (57%) had left it in monitor-only mode, where it reports on forged mail but does nothing to stop it.

Monitor mode is designed as a short first step. It lets a business confirm that its own legitimate email, such as invoices, newsletters and appointment reminders, passes the checks before anything is blocked. But in most cases, no one appears to be watching. Of the 755 monitor-only records, 480 (64%) didn’t ask for reports to be sent anywhere. Those businesses are in monitoring mode with nothing being monitored.

Part of the explanation is likely the rule many businesses were responding to. Since February 2024, Google and Yahoo have required companies that send large volumes of email to their users to publish a DMARC record, and Microsoft began enforcing similar rules for Outlook.com in May 2025. A monitor-only record satisfies those rules. It does not protect the business’s customers.

Older SPF records had problems of their own. In the sample, 327 businesses had no SPF record, 49 had published two conflicting SPF records, an error that causes mail systems to treat SPF as broken, and 70 more had records written too loosely to help. In all, 446 businesses (17%) had an SPF problem, which can both make spoofing easier and send their own email to spam.

A working SPF record is not enough by itself. Of the 2,050 businesses that could be impersonated, 1,620 (79%) had a valid SPF record. Without DMARC to enforce it, SPF tells a receiving mail server what a legitimate message looks like but not what to do with a fake one.

Your email provider won’t do this for you

Many owners assume that paying Google or Microsoft for business email takes care of security. It doesn’t. Neither Google Workspace nor Microsoft 365 publishes a DMARC record for a customer’s own domain automatically. Someone at the business, or whoever manages its domain, has to add it.

Email providerCan be impersonatedNo SPF record
Google Workspace (Gmail)
780 businesses
88%23%
GoDaddy email
79 businesses
84%68%
Other / web hosting company
825 businesses
77%10%
Microsoft 365 (Outlook)
909 businesses
71%Under 1%
Provider identified from each domain’s mail (MX) records. Zoho Mail (14 businesses) is not shown because the group is too small to compare fairly; 13 of the 14 could be impersonated.

Google Workspace customers were the most exposed: 687 of 780 (88%) could be impersonated, and nearly one in four had no SPF record either. Microsoft 365 customers did noticeably better. Only 7 of 909 were missing SPF, and 29% were enforcing DMARC, more than twice the rate among Google customers (12%).

The same gap appeared in the Santa Clara County study, which makes it unlikely to be chance. The data can’t prove why, but the setup process is a likely factor. Microsoft walks customers through adding an SPF record as part of connecting their domain, while Google treats email authentication as a separate step that is easy to skip. Businesses using GoDaddy’s email service fared worst on SPF: 68% had no SPF record at all.

No city is doing well

Metro areaCan be impersonated
New York
218 businesses
86%
Charlotte
78 businesses
85%
Houston
77 businesses
83%
Philadelphia
110 businesses
81%
Chicago
112 businesses
80%
Portland
282 businesses
80%
Austin
107 businesses
79%
Minneapolis
183 businesses
79%
Miami
52 businesses
79%
Phoenix
103 businesses
79%
Los Angeles
167 businesses
78%
Columbus
68 businesses
78%
Boston
137 businesses
77%
Dallas
123 businesses
77%
San Diego
144 businesses
76%
Detroit
76 businesses
76%
Denver
163 businesses
75%
Seattle
164 businesses
75%
Atlanta
119 businesses
74%
San Antonio
53 businesses
72%
Metro areas with at least 50 businesses in the sample. Businesses were drawn from in and around each city.

The problem was remarkably consistent from coast to coast. Every metro area with at least 50 businesses in the sample fell between 72% and 86%. New York had the highest rate, with 188 of 218 businesses exposed. San Antonio had the lowest among the larger samples, at 72%, which still means seven in 10 businesses could be impersonated.

Two cities had samples too small to rank fairly: Nashville (73% of 37 businesses) and Jacksonville (68% of 34 businesses). Neither suggests a different picture.

Large technology markets fared no better than anywhere else. Seattle, Austin, Boston and San Diego all came in between 75% and 80%. Where a business is located says little about whether its email is protected. What matters is whether anyone ever finished setting it up.

Why it keeps happening

For most small businesses, the settings that control email sit in an account no one looks at. The domain may have been registered years ago by a web designer, a former office manager or a relative who was “good with computers.” Email was set up once, it worked, and nothing ever appeared to be wrong.

That is what makes spoofing so persistent. A missing DMARC record causes no visible problem for the business. Its email still sends. Its website still loads. The harm lands on customers, often weeks later, in a way that’s hard to trace back.

Responsibility is also unclear. The web designer considers email outside the job. The email provider considers domain settings the customer’s business. The owner assumes one of them handled it. In most of the businesses we checked, the evidence suggests no one did.

What business owners can do

The fix costs nothing. For most small businesses it takes less than an hour of hands-on work, plus a few weeks of watching reports before the final change. It involves adding or editing a few text records wherever the business’s domain is managed, often the company where the domain was bought.

Find out where you stand. The free MailWatchman check reads a domain’s SPF, DKIM and DMARC records and explains the results in plain English. It doesn’t require an account.

Follow the steps for your provider. Our guides for Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Zoho Mail and GoDaddy show the exact records to add. Anyone who manages the domain, including an outside IT provider or web designer, can use them.

Finish the job. A DMARC record set to p=none is a starting point, not protection. Add a reporting address so you can see who is sending as you, and once legitimate email is passing, move to p=quarantine and then p=reject. Here’s how to move past monitor-only mode safely.

Protect domains you don’t use for email. Many small offices use a Gmail or Yahoo address for daily mail while their website runs on their own domain. That domain can still be forged. Two short records, an SPF record that authorizes no senders and a DMARC record set to reject, tell mail systems to refuse anything sent in its name.

Tell customers what you’ll never ask for by email. Even with every record in place, a clear policy helps: “We will never send new payment instructions by email. Call our office to confirm.” Any business that handles customer payments can put that line in its email signature and invoices.

Industry-specific advice: dental offices, medical practices, law firms, accountants, real estate and contractors.

About this study

Who we checked. We identified dental, medical, law, accounting and tax, real estate and contractor businesses in and around 22 of the largest U.S. cities using OpenStreetMap, a public map database, and kept those listed with their own website domain. We removed national chains, hospital and university systems, franchise brands, any domain that appeared in more than one city, and any domain shared by four or more locations in one city. That left 3,102 independent business domains.

What we checked. On October 5, 2026, we looked up each domain’s public MX, SPF and DMARC records. These records are published openly so that mail systems around the world can read them. Gathering them did not involve sending email to the businesses, logging into any system or testing anyone’s security. We excluded 366 domains that do not receive email (no MX record) and 129 that no longer existed or could not be looked up, leaving 2,607 businesses in the results. A random sample was re-checked with the MailWatchman checker, and every result matched.

How we defined the problem. A business “can be impersonated” if its domain had no DMARC record, a DMARC record set to p=none, or a DMARC record that was broken (for example, two conflicting records). In each case, mail systems are not instructed to block forged messages. The email provider was identified from each domain’s mail (MX) records.

Limits. The businesses in this study are those that appear in OpenStreetMap with a website listed. That is not a random sample of every business in each city, and some industries and cities are better represented than others. DNS records change, and a business may have updated its settings since our review. A domain that can be impersonated has not necessarily been used in a scam. To avoid creating a list scammers could use, we are not naming any business.

Sources. Figures on reported losses come from the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center’s 2025 Internet Crime Report. Business listings © OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the Open Database License.

For reporters and associations. You’re welcome to cite these findings with a link to this page. For questions, a specific city or industry breakdown, contact Ron Thoroughgood at [email protected].

Is your business one of the 79%?

Find out in seconds. The check is free, needs no sign-up, and shows exactly what to fix.