Email Security for Accountants and Tax Preparers

Every tax season, criminals pose as accountants and tax preparers to get clients to send W-2s, Social Security numbers and payments. A firm whose email domain isn’t protected makes that easy.

Free, no sign-up. Checks SPF, DKIM, DMARC, mail servers and blacklists in one go.

What our studies found in accounting firms

In our study of Santa Clara County businesses, 27 of 38 independent accounting and tax firms (71%) could be impersonated by email. Twenty-three had no DMARC record at all.

Nationally, the rate was even higher. In our study of 2,607 businesses in 22 U.S. cities, 189 of 240 accounting and tax firms (79%) could be impersonated by email.

How tax-season scams use your firm’s name

  • Document requests. “Please upload your W-2s and 1099s through this secure link before Friday.” The link goes to the scammer.
  • Fake payment requests. “Your balance due for tax preparation is $450,” or “The IRS has assessed a penalty; pay through our portal.”
  • Refund redirection. “We need to update your bank account for your refund.”
  • Forged messages to employers. A business’s payroll staff receives a request for employees’ W-2s that appears to come from the company’s outside accountant.

Without an enforced DMARC record, a scammer can send these from your firm’s exact address, and most inboxes will deliver them.

Your obligations around client data

Paid tax preparers are expected to protect taxpayer information. The IRS and FTC require them to keep a written information security plan, and IRS Publication 4557, Safeguarding Taxpayer Data, describes the safeguards it expects. Preventing criminals from impersonating your firm to clients is a natural part of that plan, and it costs nothing.

The fix

  1. SPF: include your email provider and any tax software, client portal or billing tool that sends email as you. SPF checker
  2. DKIM: turn on signing in your email provider and supporting tools. DKIM checker
  3. DMARC: monitor first, then move to p=quarantine and p=reject. DMARC checker

Step-by-step guides: Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Zoho Mail, GoDaddy.

Do it before the rush. Make the change in the fall, when you have time to watch the reports and fix any tool that fails, not in February.

Habits to add to your security plan

  • Tell clients at engagement, and in every email signature, that you’ll only collect documents through your portal and will never ask them to change bank details by email.
  • Turn on two-factor sign-in for every staff email account and your tax software.
  • Have a clear way for clients to report suspicious “firm” emails, and a plan for warning all clients if your firm is being impersonated.

Common questions

We use a client portal for documents. Isn’t that enough?

The portal protects documents once they’re inside. It doesn’t stop a forged email, sent from your address, that points clients to a fake portal. DMARC does.

Is this part of the “Security Six” or similar IRS guidance?

IRS guidance focuses on basics like antivirus, firewalls, two-factor authentication, backups and encryption. Email domain protection complements those; it protects your clients from people pretending to be you.

How long does it take to set up?

The records take minutes. A safe rollout, with a week or two of monitoring, takes two to four weeks, which is why fall is the right time.

Records break without anyone noticing

A website move, a new email tool or a DNS change can quietly undo this setup. MailWatchman checks your domain every day and emails you the moment something changes, with the fix. Plans start at $6 a month.