Email Security for Medical Practices: Protect Patients From Fake Emails

Clinics, specialists, therapists, optometrists and physical therapy offices all have something scammers want to borrow: a name patients trust and a reason to email them about bills, portals and insurance.

Free, no sign-up. Checks SPF, DKIM, DMARC, mail servers and blacklists in one go.

What our studies found in medical practices

In our study of Santa Clara County businesses, we checked 68 independent medical practices. 59 of them (87%) could be impersonated by email. Forty had no DMARC record at all, and another 19 had one set to “monitor only,” which reports on forged email but still delivers it.

Nationally, medical practices did better but are far from safe. In our study of 2,607 businesses in 22 U.S. cities, 299 of 445 practices (67%) could be impersonated by email.

How a practice’s email gets abused

  • Patient portal phishing. “You have a new message from your provider. Log in to view it.” The link leads to a fake login page that collects the patient’s portal password.
  • Fake billing. “Your statement is ready. Pay your balance of $240 here.” Patients who recently had a visit have every reason to believe it.
  • Insurance and records requests. “Please confirm your insurance and date of birth so we can process your claim.” The patient sends personal health and insurance details to a criminal.
  • Fake referrals to other offices. Emails to other practices or labs, appearing to come from you, carrying malicious attachments.

Why practices should take this seriously

Patients who fall for a forged email blame the practice. When the scam collects health or insurance information, the harm is real and hard to undo. HIPAA requires practices to safeguard patient information. It doesn’t name DMARC specifically, but stopping criminals from impersonating your office to patients is a reasonable and inexpensive safeguard.

The fix

Protecting your domain takes three DNS records, all free:

  1. SPF lists every service allowed to send your email, including your EHR, patient portal, reminder and billing systems if they send as your address. Check your SPF.
  2. DKIM signs your outgoing email. Check your DKIM.
  3. DMARC tells receivers to block forgeries. Start with monitoring, then move to p=quarantine and p=reject. What monitor-only mode means.

Step-by-step instructions: Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Zoho Mail, GoDaddy.

Don’t break your own patient notices

Medical offices often have several systems sending email in the practice’s name: the EHR, a reminder service, a review-request tool, a billing company. Before switching DMARC to reject, read a week or two of DMARC reports and make sure each of those systems passes. The reports list every service sending as your domain, which is also a useful inventory for your security records.

Habits that close the remaining gaps

  • Tell patients you’ll never ask for their portal password, card number or insurance details by email.
  • Turn on two-factor sign-in for staff email and the patient portal admin.
  • Train front-desk staff to forward any patient report of a strange “office” email to the practice manager.

Common questions

We use a secure messaging portal. Isn’t that enough?

The portal protects messages inside it. It doesn’t stop someone sending a fake “you have a new message” email that appears to come from your practice and leads to a counterfeit login page. DMARC does.

Our IT company handles email. What should I ask them?

Ask: “Is our DMARC policy set to quarantine or reject, and are SPF and DKIM passing for every system that sends as us?” Or run the free check above and send them the results.

How long does it take?

The records take minutes to add. The safe rollout, including a week or two of monitoring, takes two to four weeks.

Records break without anyone noticing

A website move, a new email tool or a DNS change can quietly undo this setup. MailWatchman checks your domain every day and emails you the moment something changes, with the fix. Plans start at $6 a month.