Four out of five small businesses in Santa Clara County have left the front door of their email open, making it easy for a scammer to send messages that appear to come from the dentist, the family lawyer or the agent handling a home sale.
MailWatchman reviewed the public email records of 366 independent businesses across the county in early October 2026, focusing on six fields where a convincing fake email can cost a client real money: dental offices, medical practices, law firms, accounting and tax firms, real estate offices and contractors. Of those, 294 (80%) lacked an enforced DMARC policy, the free setting that tells Gmail, Outlook and other mail systems to reject messages forged in a company’s name.
Only 72 of the 366 businesses, about one in five, had their domain set to block or quarantine fake mail. The rest were either missing the protection entirely or had started setting it up and stopped halfway.
Update: We have since repeated this study nationally. Across 2,607 independent businesses in 22 U.S. cities, 79% could be impersonated. Read the national study.
The gap matters because email impersonation has become one of the most expensive crimes small businesses and their customers face. In its 2025 Internet Crime Report, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center logged 24,768 complaints of business email compromise, the industry term for scams that use a trusted company’s email to redirect payments, with reported losses of just over $3 billion. Real estate fraud accounted for another $275 million. California led the nation in both cybercrime complaints and reported losses, with 116,414 complaints and $3.67 billion lost.
Those figures cover only what victims reported. They also include schemes that DMARC cannot stop on its own, such as hacked mailboxes and look-alike web addresses. But spoofing a company’s real address is the cheapest and simplest version of the scam, and for four in five businesses we checked, the door to it is still open.
How the scam works
Email was designed in an era when nobody expected to need proof of who sent a message. Anyone with basic software can put any address in the “From” line, much as anyone can write any return address on an envelope. Three records published in a company’s domain settings, known as SPF, DKIM and DMARC, were added over the years to close that gap.
SPF lists the servers allowed to send mail for a domain. DKIM adds a digital signature to each message. DMARC ties the two together and, crucially, tells the receiving mail system what to do when a message claiming to be from the company fails those checks: deliver it anyway, send it to spam, or reject it outright.
Without DMARC, or with DMARC set to its “monitor only” mode (p=none), a forged message can arrive in a client’s inbox looking exactly like the real thing. The scammer doesn’t need to break into anything. A patient receives a “past due balance” notice from what appears to be their dental office’s address. A buyer, days from closing, receives “updated wiring instructions” from what appears to be their agent. A client receives a request to send tax documents to their accountant through a new link.
The business often never knows. The fake messages don’t pass through its mail system, so they never appear in its sent folder. The first sign is usually a confused or angry call from a customer who already paid.
Healthcare and real estate are the most exposed
Share of businesses in each industry that can be impersonated by email:
Dental offices fared worst. Of 84 practices checked, 73 (87%) could be impersonated, and 60 had no DMARC record at all. About one in five dental offices (18 of 84) had neither SPF nor DMARC, the two most basic protections. Dental and medical offices hold exactly what scammers want to borrow: a trusted name, a steady flow of billing emails, and patients who expect to hear about balances and insurance.
Medical practices, including clinics, specialists, therapists and optometrists, were close behind at 87% (59 of 68).
Real estate offices posted the most telling result. Of 29 offices checked, 25 (86%) could be impersonated, but more than half of all the offices, 15 of 29, had already published a DMARC record and left it in monitor-only mode. That suggests many brokerages have heard the warnings, started the work and never finished it. The FBI’s 2025 report includes a case in which home buyers wired their closing funds to criminals after receiving fake wire instructions by email from what they believed was their title company. A single forged message at closing can redirect a buyer’s down payment.
Contractors, from roofers and plumbers to general builders, came in at 82% (55 of 67). Their exposure tends to look like fake invoices: a customer expecting a bill for a finished job receives one with new bank details.
Accounting and tax firms did better at 71% (27 of 38), and law firms did best at 69% (55 of 80). Law firms were also the most likely to have finished the job, with 25 of 80 (31%) enforcing DMARC. Even so, more than two thirds of firms that routinely handle settlements, retainers and trust-account payments can be impersonated. With tax season approaching, accountants face a familiar seasonal spike in fake requests for W-2s and payment.
Half-finished setups are common
One of the clearest patterns in the data is how often businesses started and stopped. Of the 166 businesses that had published any DMARC record, 93 (56%) had left it in monitor-only mode, where it reports on forged mail but does nothing to stop it.
Monitor mode is meant to be a short first step. It lets a business confirm that its own legitimate email, including invoices, newsletters and appointment reminders, passes the checks before it starts blocking anything. The standard advice is to stay there for a week or a few weeks, then tighten the policy. In practice, it appears many businesses publish the record to satisfy a requirement and never return to it.
Part of the reason may be that the requirement many businesses heard about doesn’t require them to go further. Since February 2024, Google and Yahoo have required companies that send large volumes of email to their users to publish a DMARC record, and Microsoft began enforcing similar rules for Outlook.com in May 2025. A monitor-only record satisfies those rules. It does not protect the business’s clients.
Problems also showed up in the older SPF records. Sixty businesses had no SPF record at all, and 15 had published two conflicting SPF records, an error that causes mail systems to treat the record as broken. Nine more had records written so loosely that they offered little protection. In all, 84 businesses (23%) had an SPF problem that can both make spoofing easier and send their own legitimate email to spam.
A big-name email provider is not a safeguard
Many owners assume that paying Google or Microsoft for business email takes care of security. The data says otherwise. Neither Google Workspace nor Microsoft 365 publishes a DMARC record for a customer’s own domain automatically. Someone at the business, or whoever manages its website and domain, has to add it.
| Email provider | Can be impersonated |
|---|---|
| Google Workspace (Gmail) 119 businesses | 92% |
| Other / web hosting company 128 businesses | 84% |
| Microsoft 365 (Outlook) 100 businesses | 61% |
Businesses using Google Workspace were the most exposed: 109 of 119 (92%) could be impersonated, and 35 had no SPF record either. Microsoft 365 customers did markedly better. Only one of 100 was missing SPF, and 39 were enforcing DMARC.
Our data can’t say for certain why. One likely factor is how each service is set up. Microsoft’s domain setup walks customers through adding an SPF record as part of connecting their domain, while Google’s setup centers on the mail routing records and leaves email authentication as a separate step that’s easy to skip. Either way, six in 10 Microsoft customers were still unprotected.
No city stands out as safe
| City | Can be impersonated |
|---|---|
| Sunnyvale 32 businesses | 94% |
| Santa Clara 17 businesses | 82% |
| Campbell 20 businesses | 80% |
| Milpitas 15 businesses | 80% |
| San Jose 178 businesses | 79% |
| Palo Alto 19 businesses | 79% |
| Mountain View 28 businesses | 79% |
| Elsewhere in the county 57 businesses | 77% |
The problem is spread evenly across the county. San Jose, with the largest sample at 178 businesses, came in at 79%. Sunnyvale had the highest rate, with 30 of 32 businesses exposed, though its sample is small enough that the figure should be read with care. No city with at least 15 businesses in the sample came in below 77%. In a region known for technology, the businesses on Main Street are no better protected than anywhere else.
Why it keeps happening
For most small businesses, the domain settings that control email sit in an account nobody looks at. The domain may have been registered years ago by a web designer, a former office manager or the owner’s nephew. Email was set up once, it worked, and nothing appeared to be wrong.
That’s the trouble with spoofing: a missing DMARC record causes no visible problem for the business itself. Its email still sends. Its website still loads. The damage lands on customers, often weeks later and in a way that’s hard to trace back.
Responsibility is also unclear. The web designer considers email outside the job. The email provider considers DNS the customer’s business. The owner assumes one of them handled it. In many of the offices we checked, the likely answer is that nobody did.
What business owners can do
The fix costs nothing and, for most small businesses, takes less than an hour of hands-on work. It involves adding or editing a few text records wherever the business’s domain is managed, often the company where the domain was bought.
Find out where you stand. The free MailWatchman check reads a domain’s SPF, DKIM and DMARC records and explains the results in plain English. It doesn’t require an account.
Follow the steps for your provider. Our step-by-step guides for Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, Zoho Mail and GoDaddy show the exact records to copy. Anyone who manages the domain, including an outside IT provider or web designer, can use them.
Finish the job. A DMARC record in monitor-only mode (p=none) is a starting point, not protection. Once reports show that legitimate email is passing, change the policy to p=quarantine and then to p=reject.
Protect domains you don’t use for email. Many small offices use a Gmail or Yahoo address for day-to-day mail while their website runs on their own domain. That domain can still be spoofed. Two short records, an SPF record that authorizes no senders and a DMARC record set to reject, tell mail systems to refuse anything sent in its name.
Tell customers what you’ll never ask for by email. Even with every record in place, a clear policy helps, such as “we will never send new payment instructions by email; call our office to confirm.” Many title companies already print this warning in their closing paperwork, and any office that handles client payments can do the same in its email signature.
About this study
Who we checked. We identified dental, medical, law, accounting and tax, real estate and contractor businesses in Santa Clara County using OpenStreetMap, a public map database, and kept those with their own website domain. We removed national chains, hospital systems, franchise brands and any domain shared by three or more locations, leaving 366 independent businesses.
What we checked. On October 1, 2026, we looked up each domain’s public MX, SPF and DMARC records. These are published openly so that mail systems around the world can read them. Gathering them did not involve sending email to the businesses, logging into any system or testing anyone’s security.
How we defined the problem. A business “can be impersonated” if its domain had no DMARC record, a DMARC record set to p=none, or a DMARC record that was malformed. In each case, mail systems are not instructed to block forged messages. The email provider was identified from each domain’s mail (MX) records.
Limits. The businesses in this study are those that appear in OpenStreetMap, which is not a random sample of every business in the county, and some industries are better represented than others. DNS records change, and a business may have updated its settings since our review. A domain that can be impersonated has not necessarily been used in a scam. To avoid creating a list scammers could use, we are not naming any business.
Sources. Figures on reported losses come from the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center’s 2025 Internet Crime Report. Business listings © OpenStreetMap contributors, available under the Open Database License.
For reporters and associations. You’re welcome to cite these findings with a link to this page. For questions or additional breakdowns, contact Ron Thoroughgood at [email protected].
Is your business one of the 80%?
Find out in seconds. The check is free, needs no sign-up, and shows exactly what to fix.